Security deposits are where landlord-tenant relationships go to die. Tenants think deductions are theft; landlords think tenants trashed the place. Both can be right. Here’s how to do it by the book.
Know your deadline
Most states give you 14–60 days after move-out to return the deposit or send an itemized deduction notice. Miss the deadline and in many states you lose the right to deduct anything — some even award the tenant 2–3x the deposit as penalty. Calendar it the day they hand over the keys.
Not legal advice — check your state’s exact statute or consult an attorney.
What you can actually deduct
- Unpaid rent and fees
- Damage beyond normal wear and tear (the hole in the wall, not the faded paint)
- Cleaning costs to return the unit to move-in condition
- Lease violations with actual costs attached
What you can’t
- Normal wear and tear. This is the #1 fight. Faded paint, worn carpet in high-traffic areas, small nail holes — that’s wear, not damage.
- Improvements you wanted anyway.
- Anything you can’t document with photos and receipts.
The paper trail that wins disputes
- Move-in condition report with timestamped photos (your only defense against “it was already like that”).
- Move-out inspection — same angles, same lighting, dated.
- Itemized deduction letter — every charge listed with amounts, sent before the deadline.
- Receipts and invoices for every repair.
One sitting, done right
The Security Deposit Deduction Notice gives you the formal notice template plus an auto-calculating refund worksheet — itemize it once, send it on time, sleep at night.
Get free sample pages + new kit alerts — email contact@dealshore.com.